Spider-Man Rankings And Opinions

Optional visual cue for the topic
You can add your own image here, e.g. a Spider-Man collage

If there’s one thing comic book fans love more than arguing about who would win in a fight, it’s ranking every version of a hero who’s already on the same side. And few heroes spark as many passionate debates as Spider-Man. Is Spider-Man 2 still the gold standard? Did the animated Spider-Verse movies quietly take the crown? Is Tom Holland your friendly neighborhood GOAT, or is Tobey Maguire still king of the skyscrapers?

To answer that (or at least start a fresh argument), this guide pulls together critic scores, box office numbers, awards, and fan chatter from across the internet. Drawing on sources like Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, IMDb lists, entertainment magazines, and fan forums in the U.S., we’ll walk through the major Spider-Man films and the actors who wear the mask, then add some honest, slightly nerdy opinions along the way. Consider this your spoiler-light, rankings-and-opinions tour through the Spider-Verse.

How We Ranked the Spider-Man Movies

Before we compare webheads, here’s the basic recipe behind these Spider-Man rankings and opinions:

• Critical reception: Aggregator scores like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic, plus general critical consensus about story, pacing, and craft.
• Audience response: Box office performance, fan scores, and general online discourse – from movie sites to Reddit threads where people insist their Spidey is the only true Spidey.
• Staying power: Cultural impact, quotable moments, meme-ability, and how often people still rewatch the movie years later.
• Spider-feels: Does it nail the core Spider-Man vibe – great power, great responsibility, and a life that’s somehow always one rent payment away from disaster?

With that in mind, let’s swing into our (admittedly subjective) ranking of key Spider-Man films.

Ranking the Spider-Man Movies (Live-Action & Animated)

1. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018)

Many lists now put Into the Spider-Verse at or near the top, and it’s not hard to see why. The film broke new ground with its bold, comic book–inspired animation and introduced mainstream audiences to Miles Morales as a full-fledged cinematic Spider-Man. It earned rave reviews, a Best Animated Feature Oscar, and quickly became a modern classic.

Beyond the style, the story hits hard emotionally: a coming-of-age tale wrapped in multiverse chaos, humor, and a surprisingly tender message about identity and self-belief. In terms of combining heart, innovation, and pure fun, this one’s tough to beat.

2. Spider-Man 2 (2004)

For years, Spider-Man 2 was the undisputed champion of Spider-Man cinema. Critics praised it for deepening Peter Parker’s character while delivering big, confident action scenes – especially that iconic train sequence.

What keeps this movie near the top of so many rankings is how human it feels. Peter’s burnout, his struggles with responsibility, and his complicated love life ground the superhero spectacle. It’s less “guy in tights fights octopus man” and more “guy in grad school has a complete life crisis… and also fights octopus man.” Relatable.

3. Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021)

No Way Home pulled off the cinematic equivalent of a nostalgia bomb, bringing together multiple generations of Spider-Man actors and villains in one multiverse event. Fans and critics praised the way it balanced huge fan service moments with a surprisingly dark emotional arc for Tom Holland’s Peter.

Besides earning massive box office numbers on par with the biggest Marvel titles, the film reenergized discussion about which Spider-Man is “best” by letting all three live-action versions share the screen. Regardless of where you rank it, it’s hard to deny its impact.

4. Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse (2023)

As a sequel, Across the Spider-Verse had a tough job: follow a beloved original, expand the world, and set up a third film. It mostly succeeds with dazzling visuals, an expanded cast of Spider-variants, and a more complex, darker story that still keeps the humor and heart. Critics scored it highly, with particularly strong praise for its ambitious storytelling and art direction.

Because it ends on a cliffhanger, some fans rank it slightly below the first film, but taken as the middle chapter of a trilogy, it’s a bold and impressive swing.

5. Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017)

Homecoming finally placed Peter firmly back in high school and within the larger Marvel Cinematic Universe. Critics and audiences appreciated its lighter tone, John Hughes–style school comedy, and a villain (Michael Keaton’s Vulture) whose motives felt grounded and understandable.

This movie leans into the idea that Peter is still learning – not just about being a hero, but about being a decent teenager with friends, crushes, and pop quizzes. It may not be the most emotionally intense Spider-Man movie, but it’s one of the most charming and rewatchable.

6. Spider-Man (2002)

Sam Raimi’s original Spider-Man was a landmark moment for superhero films in the early 2000s, combining sincere comic book melodrama with operatic action. It helped kick off the modern superhero boom and proved that audiences were ready for big-budget, somewhat earnest comic movies.

The upside-down kiss, the wrestling scene, Willem Dafoe going full “Green Goblin but make it Shakespeare” – these moments are burned into pop culture. While some of the effects and dialogue now feel a bit dated, the movie’s heart still lands.

7. Spider-Man: Far From Home (2019)

Far From Home takes Peter on a European vacation, then turns it into an extended therapy session about grief, identity, and living in Tony Stark’s shadow. The film’s illusions-heavy action sequences and twisty villain reveal give it a unique visual flavor within the Spider-Man lineup.

Some fans love its globe-trotting vibe; others prefer Peter swinging through New York. Either way, it continues Tom Holland’s strong run with a blend of humor, teen drama, and superhero stakes.

8. The Amazing Spider-Man (2012)

Rebooting the franchise just a few years after Raimi’s trilogy was controversial, but Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone brought serious chemistry to The Amazing Spider-Man. Critics were mixed, with decent but not stellar scores, yet many fans have grown more appreciative over time, especially after seeing Garfield return in No Way Home.

This version leans more into the “skateboarder genius with a camera” take on Peter. It may not top every ranking, but it’s far from the throwaway some early reviews made it out to be.

9. Spider-Man 3 (2007) and The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014)

These two often battle it out near the bottom of Spider-Man movie rankings. Both are ambitious, both are stuffed with villains, and both struggle with juggling their many subplots.

• Spider-Man 3 has memorable moments – especially the Sandman sequences – but is frequently criticized for its crowded storyline and tonal whiplash (and yes, the infamous “emo Peter” dance).
• The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is visually striking but overpacked with setup, from Electro to Green Goblin to hints at a larger Sinister Six universe that never fully materialized.

Still, even these “lower-ranked” entries have dedicated defenders, especially among fans who connected with specific character arcs or performances.

Ranking the Spider-Men: Tobey, Andrew, Tom, and Beyond

Ranking the characters is one thing; ranking the actors playing Spider-Man is another battlefield entirely. Some entertainment outlets try to create “definitive” lists, but fan opinions are all over the map.

Tobey Maguire: The Original Big-Screen Spidey

Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man is earnest, slightly awkward, and steeped in early-2000s drama. He captures the “burdened hero” side of Peter Parker exceptionally well, particularly in Spider-Man 2. For many fans, he simply is Spider-Man because he was the first one they saw on the big screen.

Pros: strong emotional arcs, iconic scenes, and a sense of weighty responsibility. Cons: his quippy, wisecracking side – a major part of comics Spidey – is a bit muted.

Andrew Garfield: The Underappreciated Outsider

Andrew Garfield often ranks higher in fan discussions than in official lists. Critics sometimes felt his movies were uneven, but his performance – energetic, witty, and deeply emotional – has aged extremely well.

He nails the banter, brings a modern edge to Peter, and sells the heartbreak in a big way. After No Way Home, many viewers re-evaluated his tenure and moved him up their personal rankings.

Tom Holland: The MCU’s Friendly Neighborhood Prodigy

Tom Holland’s Spider-Man is often praised for feeling closest to the comic-book teen version: excitable, overwhelmed, and constantly in over his head. His integration into the MCU means he gets to bounce off characters like Iron Man, Doctor Strange, and the Avengers, which adds extra fun – and extra pressure.

Holland brings a mix of innocence and quick wit, making his Spidey feel both fresh and endearing. For younger fans especially, he’s often the default “best Spider-Man.”

Shameik Moore as Miles Morales

While the live-action Peter Parkers get most of the rankings, leaving out Shameik Moore’s Miles Morales would be a crime against the Spider-Verse. His vocal performance in Into and Across the Spider-Verse grounds those visually wild movies with warmth and vulnerability.

From a rankings-and-opinions standpoint, many viewers consider Miles one of the most relatable Spider-heroes ever put on screen, animated or not.

Spider-Man’s Future: Beyond the Spider-Verse and More

The rankings conversation isn’t over, because Spider-Man’s story on screen definitely isn’t done. The animated trilogy is set to continue with Spider-Man: Beyond the Spider-Verse, now slated for a 2027 theatrical release after multiple delays.

On the live-action side, Sony and Marvel are developing future projects, including another Tom Holland–led film that will inevitably shake up where his movies sit in fan rankings in a few years.

In other words, if you think your Spider-Man opinions are locked in forever, the multiverse has some news for you.

So… Who’s the Best Spider-Man?

After sifting through critic scores, box office stats, and online debates, here’s the safest answer: it depends on what you value most.

• If you want classic superhero melodrama and big emotional swings, you probably rank Tobey Maguire and Spider-Man 2 at the top.
• If you prefer quippy energy and modern MCU connections, Tom Holland and movies like Homecoming and No Way Home may be your favorites.
• If you’re drawn to bold visuals, diverse representation, and inventive storytelling, Miles Morales and the Spider-Verse films might be your personal champions.

In practice, many fans end up with a hybrid opinion: “Tobey is the best Peter, Andrew is the best Spider-Man, Tom is the best mix of both, and Miles is the future.” There’s no single right answer – which is half the fun.

Extra: Personal Experiences and Fandom Opinions on Spider-Man Rankings

Spider-Man rankings aren’t just about numbers on a critic site; they’re also about personal history. Ask someone “What’s your favorite Spider-Man movie?” and you’ll often get an answer that tells you as much about that person as it does about the film.

Growing Up with a Spider-Man

For many people, their favorite Spider-Man is simply the first one they really met. If you grew up in the early 2000s, you might remember lining up for Spider-Man in a crowded theater, buying plastic web-shooters, and walking out ready to climb every wall in sight (not recommended). That kind of nostalgia is powerful, and it’s a big reason Tobey Maguire fans are so loyal.

Fans who came of age in the MCU era had a different experience. Tom Holland’s Peter shows up already surrounded by Avengers, tech, and crossovers. For them, Spider-Man isn’t a lonely hero figuring it out in New York – he’s part of a sprawling universe. That feels normal if that’s where you started.

Rewatching Changes Your Rankings

One interesting thing about Spider-Man movies is how much rankings shift when you revisit them. Someone might initially write off The Amazing Spider-Man films as weaker entries, then rewatch them after No Way Home and suddenly appreciate how much Andrew Garfield put into the role.

Similarly, watching Into the Spider-Verse or Across the Spider-Verse a second (or third) time often pushes them up people’s lists as they notice details in the animation, Easter eggs, and emotional beats that flew past on the first viewing.

Online Debates and Echo Chambers

Spend five minutes on a superhero subreddit or comment section and you’ll see everything from thoughtful essays to “Tobey > Andrew > Tom, no discussion.” Online fandom can amplify extreme opinions, but it also surfaces thoughtful breakdowns of why a specific scene, costume, or character arc resonates.

These spaces can reshape your rankings without you even realizing it. Maybe you never loved a certain movie, but you read a heartfelt post about what it meant to someone going through a tough time, and suddenly you see it differently. Spider-Man stories are, at their core, about trying to do the right thing while juggling everyday struggles – and that hits home for a lot of people.

How Personal Identity Shapes Favorite Spider-Men

The arrival of Miles Morales has been especially meaningful for many fans who finally saw a major superhero that looked more like them or came from a similar background. For those viewers, Into the Spider-Verse and Across the Spider-Verse aren’t just “great Spider-Man movies” – they’re central, defining pieces of representation in pop culture.

That’s a big reason why rankings that lean only on box office or critic scores can feel incomplete. Spider-Man is a symbol of resilience and responsibility that different audiences interpret through their own experiences.

The Joy of Never Settling the Debate

Maybe the best part of all these Spider-Man rankings and opinions is that they’re never final. Every rewatch, every new release, and every late-night “which Spider-Man would actually ace a physics exam?” argument can shift your perspective a little.

So instead of hunting for a single definitive answer, it’s more fun to treat rankings as a snapshot: this is where your opinions are right now. A year from now, after another marathon or a new movie, your list might look completely different – and that’s totally okay.

In true Spider-Man fashion, the story keeps swinging forward. The best you can do is hang on, enjoy the ride, and keep your personal ranking handy for the next time someone asks, “Okay, but seriously… who’s the best Spider-Man?”